Indoor VOC's
Need for Additional Study of the Causes of Worker Symptoms in Office Buildings
The results of the analyses of the CHBS and the early BASE study
data sets have indicated that emissions of VOCs from building materials,
office machines, cleaning products and water-based paints may in
some way account for SBS type symptoms commonly experienced by office
workers. It is cautioned, however, that these results are only from
two studies of relatively small numbers of buildings and that neither
study attempted to incorporate concentrations of ozone, formaldehyde
or other highly irritating pollutants. Some of these potent pollutants
are expected not to be measured by standard sampling and analytical
techniques. Furthermore, the concentrations of VOCs measured in
office buildings are generally well below levels that are believed
to elicit irritant symptoms when humans are exposed to the compounds
individually or in simple mixtures. Thus, the causal mechanisms
for irritant symptoms among office workers remain to be discovered.
Potential for Oxidation Reactions in Indoor Air to Cause Worker Symptoms
Recent studies of indoor air chemistry and the reaction of ozone
with terpene hydrocarbons such as limonene, suggest that such oxidation
reactions may produce strong airway irritants. In laboratory studies
in which mice were exposed to the reaction products of terpene ozone
mixtures, the identifiable products and residual reactants could
not account for the observed reduction in respiratory rate (Wolkoff
et al, 2000). The unexplained reduction in respiratory rate
may be due to the formation of oxygenated species that are not captured
by standard sampling and analytical techniques or chemically unstable
intermediate compounds. Exposure of the eyes of human subjects to
an aged mixture of ozone and limonene at low concentration (31 and
75 ppb, respectively) in single-blind experiments produced a significant
increase in blink frequency relative to ozone and limonene tested
individually (Kleno and Wolkoff, 2002). This
experiment supports the hypothesis that products of reactive indoor
air chemistry are strong irritants.